Paralytic Lagophthalmos Treatments

Number: 0366

Table Of Contents

Policy
Applicable CPT / HCPCS / ICD-10 Codes
Background
References

Policy

Scope of Policy

This Clinical Policy Bulletin addresses paralytic lagophthalmos treatments.

  1. Medical Necessity

    1. Aetna considers gold-weight or platinum-weight eyelid implants medically necessary for members with paralytic lagophthalmos (incomplete closure of the eyelids) as an alternative to medical therapy or tarsorrhaphy when all of the following selection criteria are met:

      1. Members are expected to have delayed, incomplete recovery of facial nerve function, and
      2. Members have exposed cornea and inadequate lacrimation, and
      3. Members have failed conservative treatment (e.g., corneal lubricants, moisture chambers, or taping of lower eyelid).

      Aetna considers palpebral springs medically necessary for members with paralytic lagophthalmos who meet medical necessity criteria for eyelid implants but have failed gold-weight or platinum-weight eyelid implants.

      Aetna considers gold-weight or platinum-weight eyelid implants, or palpebral springs experimental, investigational, or unproven for all other indications because their effectiveness for indications other than the one listed above has not been established.

    2. Aetna considers the following procedures medically necessary for chronic severe paralytic lagophthalmos associated with facial paralysis when there is no reasonable likelihood of spontaneous return of function as determined by electromyography or electroneuronography:

      • Muscle transposition surgery (including silicone sling assisted temporalis muscle transfer)
      • Neuroplastic surgery (e.g., cross-facial nerve grafting, nerve anastomoses)
      • Autologous spacing graft for lower eyelid elevation (e.g., autologous auricular cartilage, septal chondro-mucosal graft).

  2. Experimental, Investigational, or Unproven

    Aetna considers the following procedures experimental, investigation, or unproven for the treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos (not an all-inclusive list):

    • Botulinum toxin
    • Hyaluronic acid
    • Lipofilling of the upper eyelid.

  3. Related Policies

Table:

CPT Codes / HCPCS Codes / ICD-10 Codes
Code Code Description

CPT codes covered if selection criteria are met:
15760 Graft; composite (eg, full thickness of external ear or nasal ala), including primary closure, donor area [autologous spacing graft]
64864 Suture of facial nerve; extracranial [for treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos]
64865 Suture of facial nerve; infratemporal, with or without grafting [for treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos]
64885 Nerve graft (includes obtaining graft), head or neck; up to 4 cm in length
64886 Nerve graft (includes obtaining graft), head or neck; more than 4 cm length
+67320 Transposition procedure (eg, for paretic extraocular muscle), any extraocular muscle (specify) (List separately in addition to code for primary procedure) [for treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos]
67912 Correction of lagophthalmos, with implantation of upper eyelid lid load (e.g., gold weight)

CPT codes not covered for indications in the CPB:

Silicone sling assisted temporalis muscle transfer - no specific code:
15773 Grafting of autologous fat harvested by liposuction technique to face, eyelids, mouth, neck, ears, orbits, genitalia, hands, and/or feet; 25 cc or less injectate [lipofilling of the upper eyelid]
15774     each additional 25 cc injectate [lipofilling of the upper eyelid]
21282 Lateral canthopexy
64612 Chemodenervation of muscle(s); muscle(s) innervated by facial nerve, unilateral (eg, for blepharospasm, hemifacial spasm)

HCPCS codes not covered for indications in the CPB:
J0585 Botulinum toxin type A, per unit

ICD-10 codes covered if selection criteria are met:
H02.20A - H02.20C Unspecified lagophthalmos
H02.21A - H02.21C Cicatricial lagophthalmos
H02.231 - H02.239 Paralytic lagophthalmos
H02.23A - H02.23C Paralytic lagophthalmos, upper and lower eyelids

Background

Paralytic lagophthalmos describes incomplete closure of the eyelids as a result of paralysis of the seventh cranial nerve, usually from lesions affecting the nuclear or peripheral portion of the nerve.  Facial paralysis with resultant paralytic lagophthalmos and ectropion can occur from many causes, including Bell's palsy, tumors, trauma, injury, or vascular accidents affecting the facial nerve.  There is significant variability in the onset and extent of facial nerve regeneration.  The degree of recovery of facial nerve function after paralysis is influenced by the cause of the palsy, the degree of neural injury, the age of the patient, and the clinical setting.  Whatever the cause, the ocular complications of inadequately or improperly managed facial paralysis range in severity from corneal irritation and punctuate keratopathy to corneal ulceration, perforation, and blindness.

Traditional medical therapy has included emollient ointments and eye drops, as well as taping and pressure patches.  However, these are of short-lasting benefit and the frequency of application is such that these measures are often abandoned by the patients.  This has led to use of surgical procedures in the management of facial paralysis.

Tarsorrhaphy has been the usual palliative treatment of facial paralysis.  However, it has many limitations: it does not improve active eyelid closure, it restricts peripheral vision, and it is cosmetically displeasing.  Various prosthetic devices have been used to improve lagophthalmos.  These techniques often require surgical revision, and have been associated with infection and extrusion.

Gold-weight implantation in the upper lid and surgery to tighten the lower eyelid are now routine procedures for the restoration of function and cosmesis to the paralyzed eyelids.  They are simply performed and have been shown to offer consistently satisfactory results.  The literature indicates that gold weights have several advantages:
  1. they are maintenance free,
  2. implantation can be performed under local anesthesia,
  3. inflammatory reactions are uncommon,
  4. the procedure is reversible without leaving any defects,
  5. implantation can be combined with other surgical techniques (such as a lower lid tightening procedure) to obtain maximum corneal protection (marginal entropion, lower lid ectropion repair, and medial canthoplasty can be performed concomitantly,
  6. ocular cosmesis is successfully obtained, and
  7. gold is an inert metal that allows MRI scans if necessary.

Terzis and Kyere (2008a) stated that the loss of the blink reflex and the ability to close the eye actively are disabling functional and aesthetic impairments common to patients with facial paralysis.  Non-physiological (static) management techniques involve implantation of devices in the upper eyelid that mechanically aid eye closure.  The most popular devices are the gold-weight and the palpebral spring.  The authors presented their experience with these devices.  A total of 39 patients treated for paralytic lagophthalmos met the inclusion criteria – 18 received the gold-weight and 21 received the palpebral spring.  From standardized video records, pre-operative and post-operative blink scores were calculated.  Fifty-nine percent of the patients (23 of 39) were female, and the most common cause for facial paralysis [35.9 % (14 of 39)] was extirpation of acoustic neuroma and other cerebellopontine lesions.  Fifty percent of the gold-weight cohort was younger than 20 years at the time of surgery, with almost 40 % (7 of 18) younger than 10 years.  In the palpebral spring group, 14.3 % (3 of 21) were younger than 20 years, with 4.8 % (1 of 21) younger than 10 years.  The palpebral spring group obtained a larger post-operative mean blink score of 34.0 +/- 12.4 % compared with the gain of 21.4 +/- 14.6 % (p = 0.025) by the gold-weight group.  The authors concluded that the gold-weight and palpebral spring are both effective in restoring motion to the paretic upper eyelid, but the palpebral spring is more so despite the frequent need for revisions.

Terzis and Kyere (2008b) also presented their experience with the mini-tendon graft (a piece of split palmaris tendon graft) for lower eyelid suspension.  They reported that the mini-tendon graft is an effective technique for re-positioning the paralyzed lower eyelid regardless of patient age, denervation time, or cause of injury, and may be effectively combined with the eye spring or gold-weight in the presence of lagophthalmos.

Bergeron and Moe (2008) stated that the initial treatment of upper eyelid paralysis is supportive, with surgery reserved for those patients that fall into 2 categories:
  1. those who have failed non-surgical treatment to protect the cornea, and
  2.  those who have been treated effectively with conservative measures but are faced with the prospect of long-term or permanent paralysis.
There are a variety of surgical procedures that may be classified as either static or dynamic.  Standard static procedures include lid loading and tarsorrhaphy, whereas the palpebral spring implant and the temporalis muscle transfer are classified as dynamic.  The goal of the corrective procedures is to allow complete eye closure, thereby providing corneal protection, with minimal (1 mm or less) ptosis in the open position.

Schrom et al (2009) evaluated subjective patient satisfaction following implantation of different eyelid implants.  Questionnaires were sent to 42 patients treated by pre-tarsal implantation of a gold-weight (group 1) and 51 patients with a pre-tarsally fixed platinum chain (group 2).  In total, 46 response sheets were evaluated (16 x gold-weight, 30 x platinum chain) and the results were compared.  In group 1, 75 % of patients were very satisfied to satisfied with the overall result.  In group 2, 100 % of patients were very satisfied to satisfied with the overall result.  In group 1, an infection occurred in 6.5 % of patients, an extrusion in 6.5 %, and a change of vision in 31 %.  In group 2, inflammation occurred in 13 %, extrusion in 0 %, and a change of vision occurred in 13 % of patients.  On a visual analog scale from 1 to 10 (1, very good; 10, very poor), group 1 assessed the cosmetic result with an average grade of 3.8 and the functional result with an average grade of 3.1.  Group 2 assessed the cosmetic result with the grade 2.9 and the functional result with grade 3.0.  The implantation of an eyelid weight for treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos was assessed as positive by a majority of patients.  When compared with conventional gold implants, patients who have been treated with a flexible platinum chain are overall more satisfied and have a more favorable subjective view of the cosmetic results.

Silver et al (2009) noted that the gold eyelid weight, introduced nearly 50 years ago, continues to enjoy immense popularity, despite high complication rates and nearly uniform visibility under the skin.  The authors hypothesized that a commercially available, thin platinum-weight would combat the visibility of the thicker gold-weights and herein compared complication rates and visibility rates with literature-reported data for gold- weights.  Beginning in 2004, 100 consecutive patients presenting to the authors' Facial Nerve Center with paralytic lagophthalmos requiring intervention were treated with thin-profile platinum eyelid weights.  Ninety-six percent of cases were performed under local anesthesia in the office setting.  Median follow-up was 22 months.  In 102 weights placed, there have been 6 complications (5.9 %): 3 extrusions, 2 capsule formations, and 1 case of astigmatism.  All of the extrusions involved irradiated patients with parotid malignancies.  The authors concluded that this study was the first large series of thin-profile platinum eyelid weight implantations for the treatment of lagophthalmos.  This implant significantly reduces both capsule formation phenomena and extrusion compared with gold-weights and should be considered as alternative to the more conventional gold-implants.

In a retrospective interventional case series, Taban et al (2009) reported their preliminary experience using hyaluronic acid (HA) gel fillers as a non-surgical alternative in the management of congenital eyelid malpositions.  A total of 5 patients (10 eyes) with congenital eyelid malpositions, including eyelid retraction, ectropion, euryblepharon, epiblepharon, and abnormalities associated with a shallow orbit, with resultant lagophthalmos and/or keratopathy and tearing were evaluated before and after injection with HA gel (Restylane) in the pre-tarsal and/or septal regions of the affected eyelid(s).  Pre-treatment, post-treatment, and follow-up photographs were analyzed for eyelid position and degree of eyelid closure and lagophthalmos, and slit-lamp evaluation of the degree of keratopathy.  All 5 patients demonstrated significant improvement of eyelid position and degree of keratopathy.  The mean improvement in lagophthalmos was 4.5 mm (range of 2 to 7 mm).  The average volume of HA gel used was 0.5 ml per eyelid.  Complications were minor, including transient edema and ecchymosis at the sites of injection.  Of the 10 eyelids injected, only 1 had increased astigmatism after injection.  The authors concluded that HA gel shows promise as a safe and effective non-surgical treatment for the management of certain eyelid malpositions, disorders traditionally requiring surgical intervention if aggressive ocular lubrication fails.

Grusha and associates (2010) reported their first experience in using the stabilized HA preparation in patients with lagophthalmos in the presence of facial nerve palsy and thyroid eye disease and resultant keratopathy of varying degrees.  A total of 21 patients, including 15 patients with facial nerve palsy and 6 with endocrine ophthalmopathy were included in this study.  The gel was injected externally to the levator aponeurosis and/or intramuscular, and/or under the pre-tarsal portion of the orbicularis oculi muscle, and/or subcutaneously.  The use of this method led to a significant reduction of lagophthalmos and to a considerable corneal improvement.  This procedure also permitted avoidance of surgical intervention in some patients.  The mean follow-up period after injection was 11.2 months (range of 6 to 24 months).

In a review on surgical treatment options for paralytic lagophthalmos (no authors listed, 2010), it was noted that facial nerve palsy may result from a broad spectrum of causes, which is largely due to its topographic complexity.  Different types of cross plastic surgery and nerve autografting and muscle transplantation and transposition are used to recover nerve function.  Lagophthalmos is a most severe sequel of facial nerve palsy.  Blephorrhaphy and tarsorrhaphy, operations for removal of lower eyelid ectropion, and different types of palpebral fissure narrowing are used widely to correct lagophthalmos and to prevent corneal complications.  Various weight implants and special springs are employed to modify upper eyelid mobility.  The lengthening of the upper eyelid levator and the administration of botulotoxin type A and hyaluronic acid gel are proposed for additional upper eyelid descent.  The clinical value of these procedures needs to validated by well-designed studies.

In a retrospective study, Martín-Oviedo et al (2013) evaluated the safety and effectiveness of injecting hyaluronic acid gel into the upper eyelid as a non-surgical alternative for patients with temporary facial palsy.  A total of 26 patients were treated with hyaluronic acid gel injected into the pre-tarsal region of the upper eyelid.  Measurements taken before and after treatment were standardized and compared using digitized photographs.  Patients were followed-up for 1 year, and overall outcomes were assessed.  All patients initially demonstrated improvement in lagophthalmos, which decreased to 0.0 mm.  After 1 month, a significant increase in lagophthalmos was observed in 2 patients (initial fissure of 8 and 9 mm), and a platinum weight was implanted to control keratopathy.  The remaining patients (initial lagophthalmos below 6.5 mm) maintained the improvement until facial restoration.  Only 3 patients had recurrent lagophthalmos (2 mm) due to resorption, which was resolved by injecting an additional 0.3 cc.  The mean improvement in lagophthalmos was 4.6 mm (range of 3.5 to 6.5 mm).  Complications included transient ecchymosis and minimal blepharoptosis due to non-reabsorption in 5 patients.  These patients were successfully treated with hyaluronidase.  The authors concluded that the hyaluronic acid gel has proven effective in reducing paralytic lagophthalmos and controlling keratopathy in patients with temporary facial palsy, especially those with palpebral fissure with attempted closure no greater than 6.5 mm.  Injection of hyaluronic acid gel is safe, quick, and easily performed.  Furthermore, it is more cost-effective than surgery.  The level of evidence for this study was “IV”; the findings of this small retrospective study need to be validated by well-designed studies.

Friedhofer et al (2013) analyzed the use of autogenic auricular cartilage grafts as weight for the upper eyelid in conjunction with lateral canthopexy for patients with mild paralytic lagophthalmos.  This procedure was also accompanied by elevation of the lower eyelid using the cartilage graft for moderate cases.  These investigators conducted a retrospective study including case series of 30 patients with paralytic lagophthalmos from 1997 to 2010.  For mild cases, cartilage from the auricular scapha was placed in pre-tarsal space of the upper eyelid and cartilage from the concha was inserted in pre-aponeurotic space and then sutured to the levator aponeurosis in conjunction with lateral canthopexy.  For moderate cases, lower eyelid was also elevated by suturing cartilage graft to tarsum and resting it by the inferior orbital rim.  All patients had some degree of keratopathy before the intervention.  After treatment, they presented with evident clinical improvement, reduction of eye symptoms, and resolution of keratopathy.  During post-operative follow-up (mean of 37.3 months), none of the patients exhibited cartilage graft exposition, reabsorption, visibility, infection, or warping.  Complete eye closure was achieved in 24 (80 %) patients, whereas the remaining 6 (20 %) patients had residual asymptomatic lagophthalmos.  The authors concluded that the intervention using autogenic auricular cartilage grafts was only effective for the treatment of mild and moderate cases of paralytic lagophthalmos.  This out-patient surgery was associated with low morbidity and achievement of functional and aesthetic improvement.  The findings of this small retrospective study need to be validated by well-designed studies.

Lowndes Correa Francalacci et al (2023) noted that paralytic lagophthalmos can have devastating consequences for vision if left untreated.  Several surgical techniques have been described, including the use of alloplastic and autologous materials.  These researchers examined the effectiveness of the surgical treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos with combined techniques employing autologous material and involving the upper and lower eyelids.  Patients with paralytic lagophthalmos underwent stretching of the levator aponeurosis with interposition of conchal cartilage in the upper eyelid associated with sectioning of the orbito-malar ligament and lateral canthoplasty in the lower eyelid.  The effectiveness of the technique was examined by means of subjective (symptomatology) and objective parameters (ophthalmologic evaluation and measurements of lagophthalmos and marginal reflex distances 1 and 2).  A total of 8 patients with paralytic lagophthalmos were subjected to the proposed technique.  In the post-operative period, 85.7 % reported complete improvement of symptoms and 62.5 % presented a normal eye examination.  The mean lagophthalmos measurement was reduced by 5.93 mm, the mean marginal reflex distance 2 was reduced by 2.61 mm, and the mean marginal reflex distance 1 was reduced by 0.69 mm.  The authors concluded that the technique described in this study, employing autologous material associated with sectioning of the orbito-malar ligament and lateral canthoplasty, was effective in the treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos and did not present significant complications, such as extrusion.  

In a prospective interventional study, Gupta et al (2014) evaluated the effectiveness of modified temporalis muscle transfer (TMT) by silicone sling for the management of paralytic lagophthalmos.  A total of 10 patients of lagophthalmos due to facial palsy underwent modified TMT using silicone sling.  Patients were followed-up for a period of 3 months.  Palpebral aperture in primary gaze and during eye closure were assessed both pre- and post-operatively along with problems associated with lagophthalmos like exposure keratopathy and lacrimation.  Paired t-test was applied to measure the statistical outcome.  A total of 8 patients achieved full correction of lagophthalmos with no lid gap on closing the eye.  The mean (standard deviation (SD)) lid gap on eye closure was 7.7 (0.86) mm pre-operatively, 0.5 (0.47) mm at 1st post-operative day, and 0.7 (0.75) mm at 3rd month.  There was a reduction in mean lid gap on eye closure of 7 mm at 3 months (p < 0.0001) that was highly significant.  The mean (SD) vertical inter-palpebral distance during primary gaze was 12.05 (1.12) mm pre-operatively, 10 (0.94) mm at 1st post-operative day, and 10.35 (1.08) mm at 3rd month.  There was a reduction in mean vertical inter palpebral distance of 1.7 mm at 3 months (P = 0.001) which is significant.  Exposure keratitis decreased in 5 out of 6 patients at 3 months.  The authors concluded that modified TMT by silicone sling is a useful procedure with lesser morbidity and good outcomes for the treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos due to long standing facial palsy.  These preliminary findings need to be validated by well-designed studies with larger sample size and longer follow-up.

Muscle Transposition Surgery and Neuroplastic Surgery

Iskusnykh and Grusha (2015) stated that various procedures are used for the permanent correction of paralytic lagophthalmos (e.g., upper eyelid weights or spring implantation).  These investigators noted that muscle transposition surgery and neuroplastic surgery (e.g., cross-facial nerve grafting, nerve anastomoses) are not effective enough.  The majority of elderly and medically compromised patients should not be considered for such complicated and long procedures.  The authors concluded that upper eyelid weight implantation appeared the most reliable and simple treatment.

Septal Chondro-Mucosal Grafting

Alban and colleagues (2018) stated that the risk of sight-threatening complications related to facial paralysis makes palpebral fissure management a priority.  Surgery must take account of and adapt to the clinical signs of paralytic lagophthalmos.  This therefore presupposes that a sufficient therapeutic arsenal is available.  These researchers proposed a technique for palpebral lengthening (lower and/or upper), reconstructing the posterior lamella using a chondro-mucosal graft harvested from the nasal septum, combined with anterior lamellar re-positioning.  This was a retrospective, 5-year, single-center study that included 16 patients for a total of 19 septal chondro-mucosal grafts.  The only inclusion criterion was paralytic lagophthalmos.  Functional ophthalmic deficits were recorded (main outcome measure), first pre-operatively, then post-operatively.  Additionally, the degree of lagophthalmos was measured in order to infer palpebral fissure elongation gain.  Surgical consequences and complications were recorded.  A rapid regression in functional ophthalmic deficits was observed in 87 % of patients, improving in stability over time (mean follow-up interval of 34 months).  Mean palpebral fissure elongation gain was 3 mm; 53 % of patients suffered from complete occlusion of the palpebral fissure.  Surgical consequences were uncomplicated; 38 % of patients eventually underwent revision surgery.  The authors concluded that palpebral fissure lengthening using septal chondro-mucosal grafts serves as an alternative to existing treatment methods for paralytic lagophthalmos.  These investigators stated that robust functional and cosmetic results, combined with very low morbidity, made this a simple and efficient technique whose indications may be extended.  This was a small (n = 16 subjects), retrospective study; its findings need to be validated by well-designed studies.

Lipofilling of the Upper Eyelid for the Treatment of Paralytic Lagophthalmos

Biglioli and colleagues (2020) noted that lagophthalmos is one of the most unpleasant and dangerous conditions that affect patients with facial palsy.  The lack of ocular protection leads to corneal problems (such as conjunctival infections, acute and chronic keratitis, corneal ulcerations, and blindness).  A dynamic re-animation of blinking eyelids is the therapeutic gold standard. However, success is not guaranteed with these dynamic techniques; even if results are good, blinking is usually restored within a year of the initial operation.  Procedures that act more rapidly and have a higher success rate are needed.  These researchers proposed that lipofilling of the upper eyelid would improve eye closure, exploit the advantages of using autologous fat, and avoid the risks of exposure or migration associated with loading the lid with gold.  Between 2012 and September 2018, these investigators performed upper eyelid lipofilling procedures for 75 patients with unilateral facial palsy.  The main favorable result of lipofilling of the upper lid was the immediate improvement in corneal discomfort.  Subjects described a partial to total increase in corneal comfort post-operatively.  The authors concluded that in the treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos, lipofilling of the upper eyelid produced favorable aesthetic and functional results; ocular health was restored, and subjects' quality of life (QOL) was improved.  These preliminary findings need to be validated by well-designed studies with long-term follow-ups.

Suture-Less Trans-Conjunctival Insertion of Eyelid Weights

Elahi and colleagues (2022) described a novel surgical technique for implanting eyelid weights via a suture-less trans-conjunctival approach.  In comparison to the traditional supra-tarsal crease approach, this technique does not entail any external incisions or suture placement.  The procedure can reduce surgical time and complications associated with the traditional external approach.  This case series included 13 patients who underwent eyelid weight placement via the trans-conjunctival approach for paralytic lagophthalmos secondary to facial nerve paralysis (12 patients had unilateral paralysis and 1 patient had bilateral) with a total of 14 eyelid weights placed.  The procedures were carried out at an outpatient office-based surgical center.  All procedures were carried out or supervised by the same surgeon.  Patients were followed for an average 6-month post-operative period for post-operative complications.  The suture-less trans-conjunctival approach to eyelid weight insertion was successful in achieving the desired functional and aesthetic outcomes.  Patients undergoing this technique avoided the discomfort of post-operative suture removal.  All patients achieved comparable outcomes post-operatively.  There were no complications reported across the 13 patients throughout the 6-month post-operative period.  The authors concluded that this case series demonstrated that the trans-conjunctival approach for metal eyelid weight insertion was practical, relatively easy to perform, and associated with functional outcomes that were comparable to those achieved with the traditional approach, however, without external incision or placement of sutures.

Transition from an Eyelid Gold Weight to a Palpebral Spring

In a retrospective, case-series study, Salloum et al (2019) examined the outcomes of patients who transitioned from a gold weight to a palpebral spring in the management of paralytic lagophthalmos secondary to facial nerve palsy.  A total of 5 consecutive patients undergoing "enhanced" palpebral spring insertion status post-gold weight insertion were identified.  Outcome measures included visual acuity (VA), lagophthalmos, margin reflex distance 1, and corneal epithelial defects.  Subjective outcomes included need for eye lubrication, closure and rapid blink, and symptoms of discomfort and dryness.  This study was reviewed by an accredited Institutional Review Board (IRB) and granted exempt status according to federal regulations.  Mean VA post-gold weight versus post-palpebral spring was 20/200 (logMAR 1.0, S.D. -0.6) and 20/25 (logMAR 0.1, S.D. -0.1), respectively (p = 0.0214, CI: 0.231 to 1.670).  Mean lagophthalmos post-gold weight (3.5 mm, S.D. -2.8) versus post-palpebral spring (0.2 mm, S.D. -0.5).  Margin reflex distance 1 improved by a mean of 1.4 mm (gold weight -0.6, S.D. -0.5/palpebral spring -2.0, S.D. -0.4) (p = 0.0016, CI: 1.773 to -0.977).  Superficial punctate keratopathy was present in all patients with gold weights; and present in no patient post-transition (p = 0.0079).  Post-transition, 3 of the 5 patients rarely required lubrication and experienced a more satisfactory blink rate.  The authors concluded that patients with lagophthalmos as a consequence of 7th cranial nerve palsy who have undergone gold weight placement but continue to exhibit objective and subjective corneal symptoms may have symptomatic improvement with the transition to a palpebral spring.  Moreover, these investigators stated that patients with objective clinic findings of inadequate lid closure or worsening corneal epithelial defects should strongly be considered for conversion to a palpebral spring.

The authors stated that the findings of this study should be considered in the context of its limitations such as the retrospective nature of the study, a relatively small sample size (n = 5), necessary subjective variables, and that the subjects were drawn from the practice of a single surgeon.  Despite these limitations, this study provided evidence that transition from an eyelid gold weight to a palpebral spring is an adequate, and sometimes preferred, technique in an appropriate subset of facial nerve palsy patients, especially those who desire an improved dynamic lid closure mechanism without significant worsening of signs and symptoms of corneal exposure.

Akella et al (2023) stated that implantation of a palpebral spring in the upper eyelid can reduce corneal exposure in patients with paralytic lagophthalmos while also providing moderate blink dynamics; however, the spring may dislocate or be extruded, resulting in invasive and often lengthy re-operation.  These investigators recently operated on a 49-year-old woman who developed 2 firm, non-tender nodules on the upper eyelid 1 year after placement of a palpebral spring.  Pre-operative examination showed adequate blink animation with 1 mm of lagophthalmos, but given concern for extrusion the patient elected to undergo an anterior orbitotomy with exploration.  Intra-operatively, the polyester mesh pouch that surrounded the medial end of the palpebral arm of the spring was found to be securely anchored in place to the tarsus; however, the wire coursing along tarsus was bent.  This wire was mechanically straightened to lay flat.  One week post-operatively, the patient reported complete resolution of the lateral eyelid mass.  Lagophthalmos was stable at 2 mm with good blink.  Based on this patient’s clinical appearance, these researchers initially suspected dislocation of the polyester mesh pouch from its attachment to tarsus with early anterior extrusion.  Despite its dramatic appearance, simply straightening the wire provided complete resolution and prevented the need for more extensive revision or replacement.  The authors suspected that the patient may have inadvertently applied a force to the delicate spring arm (e.g., by sleeping on it, resulting in the kink).  They noted that surgeons implanting the palpebral spring should be aware of this rare potential complication, which has not been described previously.

References

The above policy is based on the following references:

  1. Abell KM. Efficacy of gold weight implants in facial nerve palsy: Quantitative alterations in blinking. Vision Res. 1998;38(19):3019-3023.
  2. Akella SS, MacIntosh PW, Setabutr P. Kinking of palpebral spring mimicking extrusion. Orbit. 2023;42(2):224-225.
  3. Alban R, Anne Sophie F, Thibault V, et al. Septal chondromucosal grafts in paralytic lagophthalmos. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018;71(9):1352-1361. 
  4. Avni-Zauberman N, Rosen N, Ben Simon GJ. Induced corneal astigmatism by palpebral spring for the treatment of lagophthalmos. Cornea. 2008;27(7):840-842.
  5. Bach CA, Raphael M, Krastinova D. The paralyzed eyelid: An alternative to gold weight, levator palpebrae lengthening. Ann Chir Plast Esthet. 2009;54(1):37-44.
  6. Bair RL. Noninfectious inflammatory response to gold weight eyelid implants. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 1995;11(3):209-214.
  7. Bergeron CM, Moe KS. The evaluation and treatment of upper eyelid paralysis. Facial Plast Surg. 2008;24(2):220-230.
  8. Biel MA. GORE-TEX graft midfacial suspension and upper eyelid gold-weight implantation in rehabilitation of the paralyzed face. Laryngoscope. 1995;105(8 Pt 1):876-879.
  9. Biglioli F, Rabbiosi D, Bolognesi F, et al. Lipofilling of the upper eyelid to treat paralytic lagophthalmos. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2020;58(5):558-563.
  10. Cabuk KS, Karabulut GO, Fazil K, et al. 2D analysis of gold weight implantation surgery results in paralytic lagophthalmos. Beyoglu Eye J. 2021;6(3):200-205.
  11. Chan RC, Chan JY. Application of palpebral spring in Asian patients with paralytic lagophthalmos. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2017;33(4):300-303.
  12. Choo PH, Carter SR, Seiff SR. Upper eyelid gold weight implantation in the Asian patient with facial paralysis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2000;105(3):855-859.
  13. Chuke JC. Bell's palsy-associated blepharospasm relieved by aiding eyelid closure. Ann Neurol. 1996;39(2):263-268.
  14. Dalkiz M, Gokce HS, Aydin A, Beydemir B. Gold weight implantation for rehabilitation of the paralysed eyelid. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2007;36(6):522-526.
  15. De Min G. Early management of the paralyzed upper eyelid using a gold implant. Acta Otorhinolaryngol Belg. 1995;49(3):269-274.
  16. Elahi E, Afshin EE, Guthrie AJ, Lo C. Sutureless transconjunctival insertion of eyelid weights: A novel technique. Ophthalmic Plast Reconstr Surg. 2022;38(1):87-89.
  17. Friedhofer H, Coltro PS, Vassiliadis AH, et al. Alternative surgical treatment of paralytic lagophthalmos using autogenic cartilage grafts and canthopexy. Ann Plast Surg. 2013;71(2):135-139.
  18. Gilbard SM, Daspit CP. Reanimation of the paretic eyelid using gold weight implantation. A new approach and prospective evaluation. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 1991;7:93-103.
  19. Gladstone GJ, Nesi FA. Management of paralytic lagophthalmos with a modified gold-weight implantation technique. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 1996;12:38-44.
  20. Grusha IaO, Ismailova DS, Ivanchenko IuF, Agafonova EI. The first experience in using the stabilized hyaluronic acid preparation to correct lagophthalmos. Vestn Oftalmol. 2010;126(1):39-42.
  21. Gupta RC, Kushwaha RN, Budhiraja I, et al. Modified silicone sling assisted temporalis muscle transfer in the management of lagophthalmos. Indian J Ophthalmol. 2014;62(2):176-179.
  22. Harrisberg BP, Singh RP, Croxson GR, et al. Long-term outcome of gold eyelid weights in patients with facial nerve palsy. Otol Neurotol. 2001;22(3):397-400.
  23. Hontanilla B. Weight measurement of upper eyelid gold implants for lagophthalmos in facial paralysis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001;108(6):1539-1543.
  24. Iskusnykh NS, Grusha YO. Correction of paralytic lagophthalmos. Vestn Oftalmol. 2015;131(2):105-109.
  25. Jackson CG. The facial nerve. Current trends in diagnosis, treatment, and rehabilitation. Med Clin North Am. 1999;83(1):179-195.
  26. Kartush JM, Linstrom CJ, McCann PM, et al. Early gold weight eyelid implantation for facial paralysis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1990;103:1016-1023.
  27. Lavy JA, East CA, Bamber A, Andrews PJ. Gold weight implants in the management of lagophthalmos in facial palsy. Clin Otolaryngol. 2004;29(3):279-283.
  28. Lowndes Correa Francalacci R, Lessa S, da Costa Aboudib JH. Auricular cartilage graft for lengthening levator muscle aponeurosis with ectropion correction for paralytic lagophthalmos. Aesthet Surg J. 2023;43(1):13-23.
  29. Loyo M, Jones D, Lee LN, et al. Treatment of the periocular complex in paralytic lagophthalmos. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2015;124(4):273-279.
  30. Martin-Oviedo C, García I, Lowy A, et al. Hyaluronic acid gel weight: A nonsurgical option for the management of paralytic lagophthalmos. Laryngoscope. 2013;123(12):E91-E96.
  31. Mavrikakis I, Beckingsale P, Lee E, et al. Changes in corneal topography with upper eyelid gold weight implants. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;22(5):331-334.
  32. May M. Gold weight and wire springs implants as alternatives to tarsorrhaphy. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1987;113(6):656-660.
  33. May M. Prospective evaluation of eyelid function with gold weight implant and lower eyelid shortening for facial paralysis. Arch Facial Plast Surg. 2002;4(1):60-61.
  34. McNeill JI, Oh Y. An improved palpebral spring for the management of paralytic lagophthalmos. Ophthalmology. 1991;98(5):715-719.
  35. Moser G. Reanimation of the paralyzed face with new gold weight implants and Goretex soft-tissue patches. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol Suppl. 1997;1:S76-S78.
  36. Nazzi V, Marras C, Broggi G. Upper eyelid gold weight implants in patients with facial nerve palsy. Surgical technique. J Neurosurg Sci. 2006;50(4):107-110.
  37. No authors listed. Surgical treatment options for paralytic lagophthalmos. Vestn Oftalmol. 2010;126(5):48-52.
  38. Nowak-Gospodarowicz I, Rękas M. Predicting factors influencing visual function of the eye in patients with unresolved facial nerve palsy after upper eyelid gold weight loading. J Clin Med. 2021;10(4):578.
  39. Rofagha S, Seiff SR. Long-term results for the use of gold eyelid load weights in the management of facial paralysis. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2010;125(1):142-149.
  40. Salloum G, Carruth BP, Hill RH, 3rd. et al. Transitioning from a gold weight to an "enhanced" palpebral spring in the management of paralytic lagophthalmos secondary to facial nerve palsy. Orbit. 2019;38(2):119-123.
  41. Sansone V, Boynton J, Palenski C. Use of gold weights to correct lagophthalmos in neuromuscular disease. Neurology. 1997;48(6):1500-1503.
  42. Schrom T, Buchal A, Ganswindt S, Knippping S. Patient satisfaction after lid loading in facial palsy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2009;266(11):1727-1731.
  43. Schrom T, Wernecke K, Thelen A, Knipping S. Results after lidloading with rigid gold weights -- a meta-analysis. Laryngorhinootologie. 2007;86(2):117-123.
  44. Seiff SR. Treatment of facial palsies with external eyelid weights. Am J Ophthalmol. 1995;120(5):652-657.
  45. Siah WF, Nagendran S, Tan P, et al. Late outcomes of gold weights and platinum chains for upper eyelid loading. Br J Ophthalmol. 2018;102(2):164-168.
  46. Silver AL, Lindsay RW, Cheney ML, Hadlock TA. Thin-profile platinum eyelid weighting: A superior option in the paralyzed eye. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2009;123(6):1697-1703.
  47. Snyder MC, Johnson PJ, Moore GF, et al. Early versus late gold weight implantation for rehabilitation of the paralyzed eyelid. Laryngoscope. 2001;111(12):2109-2113.
  48. Taban M, Mancini R, Nakra T, et al. Nonsurgical management of congenital eyelid malpositions using hyaluronic Acid gel. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2009;25(4):259-263.
  49. Terzis JK, Kyere SA. Experience with the gold weight and palpebral spring in the management of paralytic lagophthalmos. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008a;121(3):806-815.
  50. Terzis JK, Kyere SA. Minitendon graft transfer for suspension of the paralyzed lower eyelid: Our experience. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2008b;121(4):1206-1216.
  51. Tower RN, Dailey RA. Gold weight implantation: A better way? Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004;20(3):202-206.